Fans Are All Ugly... An Idol Judges His Fans' Appearance
in , ,

Fans Are All Ugly… An Idol Judges His Fans' Appearance

Former AKB48 member turned actress Shimazaki Haruka (30) is facing criticism for her comments about her male fans' appearance during a show.

During the “Love Hyena 2” broadcast on ABEMA on June 4, Shimazaki Haruka and Kashiwagi Yuki shared their experiences of “Hi-Touch Events with Fans”. These events, where idols shake hands with their fans, are uncommon in South Korea.

The fans are all ugly... An idol judges the appearance of his fans K-Selection

Kashiwagi Yuki mentioned, “More than 500 fans attend the handshake events. We usually decide whether to speak informally or formally with fans, depending on each individual. » When asked if any fans were memorable, Shimazaki Haruka replied, “I don't remember any of them. » When the host asked him if there were any men he liked among the fans, Shimazaki Haruka replied, “No. There are no handsome men among idol fans. »

The fans are all ugly... An idol judges the appearance of his fans K-Selection

Reactions from Internet users:

– “The fact that this became an article is hilariousㅋㅋㅋㅋ Where are the criticisms coming from? »

– “She’s so directㅋㅋㅋㅋ It’s not like she’s saying something wrong… It’s already a relief if they don’t smell bad…”

– “So honestㅋㅋㅋㅋ”

– “She’s just honestㅋㅋㅋㅋ”

– “She only said that there are no good-looking men among idol fans. How does it become 'All Fans Are Ugly'? »

– “The question was weird from the start, right? »

– “Even if they are not beautiful, aren’t they the ones who spent money on her??? »

– “She already had this concept from the start, even when she was an idol. She was famous for her indifferent attitude. That's what made her popular. »

– “'There are no pretty boys' = 'They are all ugly.' ?? This is a really strange way of thinking. »

– “She’s just the type of person who says things like thatㅋㅋㅋ”

– “She didn’t exactly say her fans are ugly. She just said that there are no handsome men among her fans. »

– “She’s made similar remarks before, right?” »

– “She’s always been like that, right? »

Shimazaki Haruka, known for her direct attitude, only confirms her reputation with these comments. The mixed reactions from Internet users show to what extent this kind of statement can divide public opinion.

What do you think of this statement?


Notification for
Most recent
The oldest The most popular
Online comments
Show all comments
K-pop curious

It's sad but I see exactly what she means ㅠㅠ
And when we take a little interest in Japan and idols (women!), we quickly realize that there is something quite unhealthy that can be at play there...


I didn't know her but it must be said, she is very pretty, I must admit, and personally I prefer someone who says things rather than saying it with a big smile without thinking like a robot. Here the only problem that I see is that she is a public person and also a former idol who became an actress so I think that she could have qualified her remarks such as "that they were not to her taste" but it It's his character who is like that according to the comments so you have to accept it and rebel and it won't change anything.


She doesn't look like a miss either to open her mouth to criticize other people's appearance.

Suzy: 'Infinitely' Happier Than Her Day as a Kpop Idol K-Selection

Suzy: 'Infinitely' Happier Than Her Days as a Kpop Idol

New controversies have arisen around Netflix K-drama “Hierarchy” K-Selection

New controversies have arisen around Netflix K-drama “Hierarchy”