Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection
in ,

Past Accusation of Bang Si Hyuk's BTS Plagiarism Against SHINee Resurfaces, Netizens Blame Producer

Following the ongoing situation between HYBE Labels and ADOR CEO Min Hee Jin, numerous accusations of plagiarism have been leveled against various K-Pop artists produced by Bang Si-Hyuk. Min first accused ILLIT of plagiarizing NewJeans with the consent of the HYBE founder. With all of this chaos going on and numerous accusations of plagiarism, an old case where HYBE Labels artist BTS was accused of plagiarism against another K-Pop group has resurfaced, sparking some interesting reactions from the share of Korean Internet users.

The allegations date back to BTS's HYYH era, around 2015 and 2016. The various outdoor camping-themed images and concepts used for the Young Forever era in particular have been compared to SHINee's 2014 Japanese single , “Lucky Star.” For example, both groups used rainbow-colored hot air balloons in their concepts.

Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection

Concepts of both groups also include a campfire with members gathered in the dark. On a forum where the past controversy was discussed, the comparison was also made with the camper used in both concepts. There have even been accusations against BTS for having accessories and clothing similar to some SHINee members.

Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection

  Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-SelectionPast accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-SelectionPast accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection 

As with other cases of plagiarism accusations, it can be argued that this type of concept does not belong to any particular artist, and is basic enough to have been created by the BTS team with no intention of copying. SHINee. However, some Korean netizens remember the initial accusations and how serious they were at the time.

  • “At the time, I thought SHINee fans said something, but everyone turned a blind eye to BTS. »
  • “Because of Bang Si Hyuk’s greed, BTS became a target”
  • “It’s embarrassing, but they must have known all about it. »
  • “I remember it being considered controversial at the time. »
  • “It’s been a long time since I’ve seen this. It's not just one or two things, it's ridiculous. »
  • " It's embarassing. »
  • “Wow, I discovered this for the first time, what is this. »
  • “At that time, SHINee fans must have been really frustrated. »
  • “Wasn’t there more to it than that?” »
  • that reminds me of that

Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection

Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection Past accusation about Bang Si Hyuk's plagiarism for BTS against SHINee resurfaces, netizens blame producer K-Selection

  • Bang Si Hyuk fooled us all
  • Deabak…Is this what Min Hee Jin was talking about when she said Bang Si Hyuk copied her?

Nearly a decade ago, this situation occurred without much impact on either group. However, it's always interesting to look back in K-Pop history at times like this and realize that some things haven't changed much when it comes to the plagiarism accusations going around!

What do you think ?

source

Subscribe
Notification for
guest
7 Comments
Most recent
The oldest The most popular
Online comments
Show all comments
Doggie

And here's another timely witch hunt. Everyone rushes into the breach to make it a crater whatever you want in the end. I hope BTS didn't use anyone's toothbrush (reference in a clip) because there for once….
I'm not Army strictly speaking, I'm just Jin seeing Suga but I also like other groups but here I'm saying enough is enough, you're going to give up on everyone. We shoot at the ambulance in all directions but wait for it to stop to take the wounded and see the dead and there who will live will see and those who shoot today and play the fathers or mother virtue with a Kleenex and who has started all this in Ms. dress almost everyone by leaving their CEO set in the cloakroom to better make local color and pity, will show who they really are. A disguise is removed very quickly and generally at the doors of the court. It's there that the appointment is set and we'll see who's right.
There are a lot of clips that look the same and that we didn't invent anything, we're not complaining. Or make songs without visual supports but there too there are similarities and plagiarism comes out every day. Are you aware that there is no great invention and that in the end we go around in a loop?? So pity Before playing the outraged astonished service, sweep apparently irreproachable people in front of your door. The success of some has always aroused jealousy and envy in others. You don't like it so move on, you don't have to stay watching or hearing and so you will be happier and less hateful. On this for my part I summarized all this story

Kayarisbts

Damn Thank you, if everyone could let people get on with their lives, we wouldn't be here

Seagull

And go!! Have people gone crazy? These cases are on average 10 years old and as RM explained these concepts were common for all groups of boys of that age!! They were even attacked on school costumes!! It’s really becoming rubbish!! The haters can no longer find anything to eat so we dig up comments “classified as unjustified” from the time? You really don’t think BTS has suffered enough? These attacks are despicable, especially for young people who are currently in military service...I hope that ARMYs will react to protect the boys!!

Wonyoungism

It's not about sending hate to groups. You did not understand the article. Bang PD is accused of plagiarism. Where have you seen hatred towards BTS, stop twisting the words. And it doesn't even surprise me that he is accused of plagiarism even a concept can't be similar to this point it's shocking. Yes there are concept trends but tell me another group that had the same concept as SHINee with the hot air balloon, the campfire etc. before or even after the “plagiarism photo concept” for the group BTS. Person. So we're talking about plagiarism, not a trend that boygroups follow. Moreover a scandal has the right to resurface time is not limited only to the present, it's as if you did not have the right to rehash your memories, it would therefore be a question of choosing much better words and build a real critique of the situation and not bring back BTS again and again, they have never insulted them as far as I know, the same for NewJeans. They have nothing to do with the story, they are just facts that are questioned by fans about Bang PD. The words of artists have nothing to do with history currently, so even if your favorite singer says this or that, only justice will do real work without being under the influence of celebrities who can easily twist the brains of their fans and therefore attract only negativity and opposition while forgetting the pacifist side that all fans must currently feel.

dikra ​​korari of roko kenitra

i love btsssssss soo muche
emd i hate blak pimkkkk

Seagull

I also really like BTS since I'm ARMY...but openly hating any group won't help us...Please remain courteous and don't stoop to the level of haters please..

Netflix's 'Goodbye Earth' Ending Explained + K-Selection Recap

Netflix's 'Goodbye Earth' Ending Explained + Recap

“Genie Studio” Unveils Its Current K-drama Slate for 2024 K-Selection

'Genie Studio' Reveals Its Slate of Ongoing K-dramas for 2024